Climate Change Laws of the World will soon be upgraded to be AI powered, see full announcement
Germany flag
Germany

Higher Regional Court of Koblenz's decision on company's climate neutral claims regarding grave lights

Jurisdiction: Higher Regional Court of Koblenz


Side A: Centre for Protection against Unfair Competition (Ngo)


Side B: Anonymous party (Corporation)


Core objectives: Whether advertising on grave lights as ‘CO2 neutral’ or ‘climate neutral’ is a misleading commercial practice 


Summary
The defendant, who sold grave lights, had advertised these on product labels and in a catalogue as ‘climate neutral’ and ‘CO2 neutral’. The Centre for Protection against Unfair Competition filed a claim in the Regional Court of Koblenz arguing that the advertising claims were misleading.

The Regional Court of Koblenz concluded that the advertising claims ‘CO2 neutral’ and ‘climate neutral’ were misleading and breached § 5 para. 1 of the Act against Unfair Competition. The Court held that consumers understood this advertising in the sense of the grave lights not having a negative impact on the CO2-content of the atmosphere. 

The defendant appealed this decision and stated that consumers understood the advertising claims ‘CO2 neutral’ and ‘climate neutral’ as meeting the technical requirements of these terms. The defendant argued that, in any case, they were taking measures to compensate the CO2 emissions by planting trees. 

The Higher Regional Court of Koblenz upheld the Regional Court’s ruling. In doing so, it relied on the strict standard established by the German Federal Court of Justice on environment-related advertising claims. The Higher Regional Court insisted that climate neutrality meant complete compensation of CO2 emissions. It found that the compensation measures such as planting trees had not sufficed to achieve complete compensation, in fact, the CO2 footprint had not even been calculated. The appeal was therefore upheld under § 5 para. 1 of the Act against Unfair Competition.
Case documents

from the Grantham Research Institute
from the Grantham Research Institute
Publication banner
Climate Change Laws of the World uses cookies to make the site simpler. Find out more about cookies >>